A popular alternative to eddy brakes is the water brake, in particular for those testing engines at the crank. The braking is controlled by adjusting the water flow, which can be done manually or electronically. More water in the brake = more braking. Note that the braking force is not determined directly by the valve opening, it is the fill level that determines the braking force. Water brakes are typically light and have the benefit that the heat generated is only heating up the water, which you can have in a very large container or cool down at low cost, so long runs and very high horsepower can be sustained. They have a unique property in that they can tolerate very high RPMs, so they can be connected directly to the engine crankshaft.
Water brakes can be tricky to control and the setup can be challenging. The water pressure needs to be very constant and quite high (~3-5 bar). For high horsepower setups, water pumps of 4-6kW is normal! The valve also has some special requirements. Ideally we want a linear response, i.e. 50% brake input should produce twice the flow as 25% input. If you use a normal ball valve, this will not work, since a ball valve (and many other valves) have a very abrupt start and nothing much happens after the valve being half opened. The valve is controlled either by a stepper motor or a powerful servo.
Here are two examples of water brake valves. Notice the very small water passage for low valve openings.
See this link on setting up YourDyno with water brakes.
August 25, 2019 @ 4:38 am
Hello, I have a Heenan & froude brand absorption unit, the speed control is by means of a pulsating controlled hydraulic valve. Is your system capable of handling that type of control?
If so, could I read acceleration mode in increments of 300 rpm per second?
August 25, 2019 @ 8:45 am
Hi, so the control is via Pulse Width Modulation? With a small modification to the PWM logic we can support that, we need to support the frequency it needs. Do you know (roughly) the control frequency? Maybe 5Hz or so?
May 29, 2022 @ 4:40 pm
Hello! Thrid photo… What is this type of valve called?
May 29, 2022 @ 5:12 pm
Jhon, this is the Dynomite valve. They are not available anymore.
YourDyno has water brake valves now. They are not fully released yet, but orders are accepted and deliveries have started. Contact me at email@example.com if you are interested.